Family Dynamics after a Dementia Diagnosis: Part 3
When Family Members See Different Paths
When Old Wounds Reopen: Navigating Family History During Dementia Care
This is something that might sound familiar--dementia has a way of pulling off all the carefully placed bandages that have been covering your family's old wounds. Suddenly, you're not just dealing with mom's memory loss; you're right back in the middle of family dynamics that have been simmering for decades.
Remember how your family had its little ecosystem growing up? Maybe you were "the responsible one," your sister was "mom's favorite," and your brother was "the one who got away with everything." You thought you'd outgrown those roles years ago—until now.
Suddenly, you find yourself slipping right back into old patterns. If you were the family fixer, you might automatically take charge of your parent's care, even at significant personal cost. If you were the rebel, you might be pushing back against your siblings' care decisions almost reflexively.
And here's the thing—it's happening to all of you. Your sister, who constantly competed with you for attention, might challenge every care decision you make. Your brother, who escaped family responsibility by moving across the country, still finds reasons he can't help much.
These aren't conscious choices. We all revert to old, familiar roles during stress—it's human nature. But recognizing when this happens can help you break these patterns.
When Parents Played Favorites
Many parents had favorites, and everyone knew it. If you were the child who never quite measured up in your parent's eyes, being expected to provide care now can stir up complicated feelings.
"Why should I put my life on hold for someone who always preferred my sister?"
"Dad criticized everything I did my whole life, and now I'm supposed to manage his care?"
These feelings aren't pretty, but they're real. Ignoring them won't make them go away—it just pushes them underground, where they can cause even more damage.
On the flip side, if you were the favored child, you might feel an overwhelming responsibility to care for your parent, coupled with resentment that your siblings aren't doing more. You might even struggle with guilt that you're not doing enough to justify the preferential treatment you received.
When Some Family Members Disappear
One of this journey's most painful aspects is watching certain family members step back completely. Maybe your sister visits once a year and offers plenty of advice but no practical help. Or perhaps your brother hasn't even acknowledged mom's diagnosis.
This absence reopens old feelings of abandonment, mainly if this pattern has existed. The sense that "I'm always the one left holding the bag" can build into deep resentment over time.
There's often more beneath the surface for family members who step back. Sometimes, it's pure avoidance—they can't bear to see their parent change. Other times, it's rooted in their own trauma or unresolved relationship issues with the parent. And sometimes, it's simply that life circumstances—their health issues, financial struggles, or geographic distance—create genuine barriers.
Finding a Better Way Forward
These old wounds and family patterns can feel like quicksand, pulling you down when you need solid ground. But there are ways to navigate this terrain more skillfully:
Name what's happening. Sometimes just acknowledging the elephant in the room can defuse its power. "I notice I'm falling back into my old role as the family problem-solver and taking on too much." Or "I think some of our disagreements about mom's care might be connected to our old rivalry patterns."
Look for empathy where you can. Your sister, who rarely visits, might be struggling with anxiety or depression that makes caregiving overwhelming. Your brother, who seems controlling, might be acting from fear rather than a desire for power. This doesn't excuse harmful behavior but understanding it can help you respond more effectively.
Set boundaries with care. You can say no without closing the door completely. "I can't be the only one handling Dad's doctor appointments, but I can take him every other time if we create a schedule." Or "I need to limit my caregiving to weekends because of my work schedule, but I'm fully committed to those times."
Seek support outside the family. Sometimes the healthiest thing is to accept that your family has limitations and look elsewhere for support. Friends, support groups, faith communities, and professionals can provide the understanding and help your family may be unable to offer.
Consider family therapy. If your family is open to it, a few sessions with a family therapist specializing in elder care issues can help break unproductive patterns and establish new communication methods. Even if only some family members participate, it can make a difference.
A Word About Forgiveness
The weight of old resentments becomes increasingly heavy as the dementia journey continues. At some point, you might need to work toward forgiveness for your well-being—not because what happened wasn't wrong but because carrying that pain takes energy you need for other things.
This doesn't mean forgetting or excusing harmful behavior. It means setting down the burden of resentment, so it doesn't continue to shape your present and future.
Remember, your parent's dementia didn't create these family dynamics—it simply magnified what was already there. And while you can't change your family's past, you have choices about how you respond now. Sometimes the most powerful option is to break old patterns, even when others aren't ready to do the same.
Be gentle with yourself through this process. You're doing your best in a situation no one would choose. And know that many others walking this path have felt exactly what you're feeling—you're not alone in this struggle.
Moving Forward Together
This journey with dementia will test your family in ways you never imagined. The arguments over care decisions, the financial strains, the resurfacing of old wounds are all part of this challenging path. But here's what I want you to remember: this journey, with all its challenges, also offers the possibility of healing and connection. Many families find that by facing these struggles together, they grow closer, developing more profound understanding and compassion for one another. Even when the path seems darkest, look for those small moments of grace—the day your brother unexpectedly steps up, the conversation where you finally understand your sister's perspective, or the peaceful afternoon when everyone puts aside their differences to be present with your loved one.
No family navigates this perfectly, and that's okay. What matters most is facing them with as much honesty, patience, and love as you can muster. While caring for your loved one with dementia, you're writing the final chapter of your shared family story. Make it one of love—imperfect, sometimes messy, but real.
Family Dynamics after a Dementia Diagnosis: Part 2
When Family Members See Different Paths
When Money and Authority Complicate Dementia Care
When your loved one can no longer manage their affairs, conversations about money and legal authority can bring long-simmering family tensions to a boil. Let's talk honestly about these challenges and how you might navigate them with less stress and more understanding.
"Who's in charge here?" - The power dynamics of decision-making
Remember when mom or dad was the one making all the decisions? Now suddenly you and your siblings are deciding things for them, and it's uncomfortable territory for everyone.
If you've been named the power of attorney, you might feel the weight of responsibility—and possibly the suspicious eyes of your siblings watching your every move. If you're not the designated decision-maker, you might worry about being left out of essential choices or disagree with how things are handled.
This shift in family authority rarely happens smoothly. Your sister, who manages the finances, might feel defensive when questioned about expenses. Your brother might feel his opinions are being dismissed when he raises concerns about Dad's care. These dynamics aren't really about the money—they're about trust, control, and sometimes, old family patterns repeating themselves.
What helps? Transparency goes a long way. If you manage the finances, consider regular family updates with transparent accounting. If you're concerned about how things are being handled, try approaching your questions with curiosity rather than accusation: "I'm trying to understand the financial situation better. Could we talk about the monthly expenses?"
"We can't afford this" - The crushing reality of care costs
Nothing prepares you for the sticker shock of dementia care. When looking at $5,000 to $15,000 monthly for a memory care facility or $25 an hour for in-home help, tensions about money can escalate quickly.
The most complex conversations often center around the family home. You might see it as the logical asset to sell to fund care, while your sister sees it as the family legacy that should be protected at all costs. Or perhaps you've been caring for mom in her home and feel that selling it would displace both of you, while your brother is pushing for a sale to pay for professional care.
These aren't just financial disagreements, they're emotional ones. That house represents different things to different family members. For some, it's just a building; for others, it's the physical embodiment of childhood memories and security.
What helps? Try to separate the practical from the emotional when making these decisions. A financial advisor specializing in elder care can offer objective advice about funding options you might not have considered. And if selling assets becomes necessary, find ways to honor what's being lost—perhaps by creating memory books of the family home or setting aside unique keepsakes.
"That's my inheritance disappearing" - The uncomfortable truth about expectations.
It's the elephant in the room that no one wants to acknowledge: As your loved one's care costs mount, the assets that might one day come to you are dwindling. While everyone agrees that mom's care comes first, the reality of watching potential inheritance disappear can trigger complicated feelings.
Maybe you were counting on that inheritance to help fund your retirement or your children's education. Perhaps you feel guilty for even thinking about it while your parent is still alive. Or maybe you suspect that your brother insists on less expensive care options to preserve his future inheritance.
These concerns feel uncomfortable to express, but they're entirely normal. Money matters to all of us, and pretending it doesn't only drive these discussions underground, where they can create even more division.
What helps? First, acknowledge that feelings about inheritance don't make you a bad person. Second, consider having open conversations about expectations—not to demand specific outcomes, but to understand each other's perspectives and financial situations. Some families even find it helpful to involve a mediator in these discussions, someone who can help create a safe space for honest communication.
Finding a path forward together
When it comes to navigating these complex financial and legal waters, here are some approaches that have helped other families:
Please put it in writing. Create clear, written agreements about who's responsible for what, how money will be managed, and how decisions will be made. This reduces misunderstandings and provides a reference point when questions arise.
Seek professional guidance. An elder attorney can help you understand options like Medicaid planning, trusts, and other legal tools. A financial advisor with expertise in elder care can help you maximize resources and explore funding alternatives.
Consider a professional fiduciary. If family tensions make it impossible to agree on who should manage finances, a professional fiduciary can serve as a neutral third party, managing assets according to your loved one's best interests.
Focus on your shared goal. When discussions get heated, bring the conversation back to what you all want: the best possible care and quality of life for your loved one. This common ground can help you work through disagreements more productively.
Be kind to yourself and each other. This is complicated territory for everyone. You're all doing your best in a situation none of you would have chosen. A little grace and forgiveness can go a long way for yourself and your family members.
Remember, while the financial and legal challenges of dementia care can be daunting, they don't have to tear your family apart. You can find your way through this difficult time together with open communication, clear agreements, and a focus on your shared commitment to your loved one's wellbeing.
Effective Communication in Dementia Care
Navigating the Conversation
Communication is the bridge that connects us all, but when dementia enters the picture, that bridge requires careful maintenance and sometimes complete reconstruction. As cognitive abilities change, so must our approach to communication. This isn’t just about being understood—it’s about preserving dignity, reducing frustration, and maintaining meaningful connections despite the challenges dementia presents.
Adapting Your Communication Style as Abilities Change
When supporting someone with dementia, communication strategies must evolve alongside cognitive changes. What works in early stages may become ineffective as the condition progresses.
In early stages, simple accommodations make a significant difference. Reduce background noise during conversations, maintain eye contact, and speak clearly without raising your voice unnecessarily. Allow extra time for processing and responding—rushing only creates anxiety and confusion.
As abilities change in moderate stages, incorporate more visual cues. Demonstrate what you’re discussing, and when possible, use simple sentences with familiar words, and break instructions into manageable steps. Remember to introduce yourself and explain what you’ll be doing, even with people you’ve known for years.
In advanced stages, non-verbal communication becomes increasingly important. A gentle hand on the shoulder, a warm smile, or a reassuring tone may communicate care more effectively than words. Pay close attention to body language and facial expressions that signal discomfort, pain, or distress when verbal expression becomes limited.
The Art of Responding to Repetitive Questions
Few aspects of dementia care test patience more than answering the same question multiple times within minutes. Understanding the underlying need behind repetitive questions helps respond with compassion rather than frustration.
Repetitive questions often stem from insecurity, anxiety, or the simple inability to remember asking before. Rather than saying “I already told you,” try these approaches:
- Answer as if it’s the first time they’ve asked
- Validate the emotion behind the question: “You seem concerned about your doctor’s appointment”
- Redirect gently after answering: “Let’s look at these family photos now”
- Create visual reminders when possible (calendars, notes, pictures)
- If the same question persists, consider whether an unmet need exists—hunger, discomfort, or loneliness can manifest as repetitive questioning
Remember that the person isn’t trying to be difficult—their brain simply isn’t storing the information. When you respond with patience, you’re addressing both the question and the emotional need for reassurance.
Beyond Words: The Power of Non-Verbal Communication
As dementia progresses, the ability to process verbal language often diminishes, but sensitivity to emotional tone and body language frequently remains intact. Your non-verbal cues may communicate more powerfully than anything you say.
Effective non-verbal communication includes:
- Maintaining a calm, pleasant facial expression
- Using gentle touch when appropriate and welcomed
- Approaching from the front within the person’s line of vision
- Matching your body language to your words
- Keeping gestures slow and deliberate
- Using visual demonstrations alongside verbal instructions
Remember that people with dementia often mirror the emotional energy you bring to interactions. If you appear rushed, frustrated, or anxious, those emotions will likely transfer to the person you’re supporting, escalating challenging situations.
Validation vs. Reality Orientation: Finding the Right Balance
For decades, caregivers were taught to orient people with dementia to reality—correcting misconceptions and reminding them of the present time, place, and situation. While this approach sometimes helps in early stages, it often creates unnecessary distress as dementia advances.
Validation therapy, pioneered by Naomi Feil, offers an alternative approach. Rather than correcting inaccurate statements or beliefs, validation therapy focuses on the emotional truth behind communications.
When someone asks for their deceased parent, responding with “Your mother died 20 years ago” may be factually correct but emotionally devastating—forcing them to grieve that loss anew. Instead, validation might involve saying, “You’re thinking about your mother today. What was she like?” or “Tell me about her cooking—you’ve mentioned before how much you loved her apple pie.”
This doesn’t mean fabricating falsehoods. Rather, it means focusing on emotional needs rather than factual accuracy. The goal is comfort and connection, not perfect orientation to reality.
The most effective approach often combines elements of both techniques, adapted to the individual’s needs and cognitive status:
Early stages: Gentle reality orientation when helpful, balanced with emotional validation
Middle stages: Increasing emphasis on validation with simple reality cues when necessary
Advanced stages: Focus primarily on validation and emotional connection
Effective communication in dementia care isn’t about finding perfect words—it’s about creating moments of connection despite cognitive changes. By adapting your approach as abilities change, responding compassionately to repetitive questions, harnessing the power of non-verbal communication, and balancing validation with reality orientation, you create spaces where meaningful interaction remains possible.
These techniques require practice, patience, and the willingness to enter the changing reality of someone with dementia. Though challenging, the moments of genuine connection these approaches facilitate are worth every effort.
Taking Action: Strengthening Your Communication Skills
This week, choose one communication technique from this article to practice deliberately during interactions with your loved one. Notice what works and what doesn’t, remembering that effective strategies will change over time and even throughout the day.
Consider keeping a small journal of successful interactions—what approach worked in which situation? These notes become invaluable as you refine your personal communication toolkit.
Finally, extend grace to yourself when communication breaks down. Even with perfect technique, there will be difficult moments. What matters most is returning with renewed patience and willingness to try again.
When Sadness Isn't Just Dementia
A Caregiver’s Guide to Recognizing Depression
Depression in dementia patients is something I’ve seen impact many families, and it breaks my heart how often it goes unrecognized or untreated. Having worked with these patients, I’ve noticed that up to 40% experience significant depressive symptoms, yet these can be mistaken for the progression of dementia itself.
The relationship works both ways – depression can increase someone’s risk of developing dementia later, and dementia often triggers depression as the person experiences losses in their abilities and independence. It’s a cruel cycle.
I know this intimately. When my husband was diagnosed with early dementia at just 55, our world shattered. He was still in the prime of his career and suddenly faced a future very different from what we had planned. At first, I attributed his withdrawal and sadness to processing the diagnosis. But months passed, and as he became increasingly detached, a specialist recognized what I hadn’t – he was experiencing severe depression alongside dementia.
What makes this particularly challenging is how the symptoms blend. When your loved one withdraws from activities they once enjoyed, is it depression or advancing dementia? When they seem less interested in eating, is it depression affecting appetite or something else? With my husband, his loss of interest in making and fixing things – something he’d loved for decades – was a key signal we missed.
I’ve found that treatment works best with a thoughtful combination of approaches like careful medication management (though responses can be unpredictable), along with meaningful activities like music therapy or reminiscence work that connects them to positive memories. Creating predictable daily routines provides security when their world feels increasingly confusing. For us, establishing a daily walk together became both physical exercise and valuable connection time when conversations grew more difficult.
And please, don’t forget yourself on this journey. Caregiver burnout and depression are real risks that can affect both your well-being and your ability to provide the best care. What support system do you have in place? I learned this lesson the hard way, trying to handle everything alone until my own health began to suffer.
If you’re caring for someone with dementia, I urge you to watch carefully for signs of depression and advocate for proper assessment. Addressing depression isn’t optional in dementia care—it’s essential for preserving the quality of life for both your loved one and yourself.
Handling Hurtful Words from Your Loved One with Dementia
I remember the first time my father looked me straight in the eye and said, "You've stolen my money. I want it back now." My heart shattered. After spending hours each day caring for him, this accusation felt like a slap in the face. If you're experiencing something similar, I want you to know—you're not alone in this, and there are ways through it.
What's Really Happening When They Say These Things
Few things hurt more than being accused, rejected, or misidentified by someone you're pouring your heart into caring for. The painful statements come in many forms:
"You're not my daughter. Get this stranger out of my house!"
"Why are you poisoning me?" (when offering medication)
"I never loved you anyway."
"You're keeping me prisoner here."
"You never visit me." (despite your daily presence)
"You've stolen my money." (when they've misplaced something)
Here's what helped me: understanding that when Dad accused me of theft, it wasn't actually Dad speaking—it was him trying to make sense of a world that increasingly confused him. His brain, damaged by dementia, was creating explanations for why he couldn't find his things. And unfortunately, we caregivers are the easiest targets for these explanations.
The Secret Pain Caregivers Rarely Discuss
Can I be vulnerable with you for a moment? The physical tasks of caregiving—the bathing, medication management, and doctor's appointments—weren't what broke me down. It was these moments of verbal aggression that sent me crying to the bathroom.
You might be experiencing:
- That gut-punch feeling when they accuse you of something you'd never do
- The grief that washes over you when your parent doesn't recognize you
- The exhaustion of constantly managing your emotional reactions
- Guilt for sometimes feeling angry, even when you know it's the disease
I've felt all of these, and I want you to know it doesn't make you a "bad" caregiver. It makes you human.
What Works (When Logic Doesn't)
Through trial and considerable error, I've found approaches that don't work (arguing, correcting, presenting evidence) and some that actually help. Let me share what's made the biggest difference:
Meet Them in Their Reality, Not Yours
When Dad accused me of stealing his money, saying "No Dad, I didn't take your money" only escalated things. Instead, I learned to say, "You're looking for your money? That's important. Let's look for it together."
The magic here? I validated his concern without confirming the accusation.
Look for the Need Behind the Words
I noticed something eye-opening: Dad's accusations often came when he was feeling something else entirely—fear, confusion, discomfort, loneliness.
When he said, "You're keeping me prisoner," what he actually meant was "I feel unsafe and confused." Addressing that underlying emotion—"You seem worried right now. I'm here with you. You're safe"—often dissolved the accusation entirely.
Your Secret Weapon: Body Language
They might not follow your words, but they absolutely read your energy. I found that kneeling at Dad's eye level, keeping my voice soft, and moving slowly communicated safety and love when my words couldn't get through.
When You Need More Than Advice
Some situations need professional intervention:
- If accusations come with physical aggression
- When verbal aggression suddenly increases (which can indicate pain or infection)
- If you're experiencing caregiver burnout (yes, it's real, and no, you can't just push through it)
Don't wait until you're drowning. I did that, and looking back, we both would have benefited if I'd reached out sooner for:
- A medication review with their doctor
- A consultation with a geriatric psychiatrist
- Home health assistance, even temporarily
- A dementia-specific support group (these people get it like no one else can)
Protecting Your Heart While Giving It Away
I've learned that compassionate caregiving requires fierce self-protection. For me, this means:
- A sticky note on Mom's bathroom mirror that says "It's the disease, not Dad."
- A code word I text to a friend when I need a 20-minute rescue call.
- Five minutes of deep breathing in my car before start the day.
- Allowing myself to feel hurt without judging that feeling
These are what allow me to show up as the caregiver I want to be.
The Truth That Keeps Me Going
On my hardest days, I remember this: somewhere inside, beneath the confusion and fear, the person I love still exists. The disease has hijacked their ability to express themselves, but it hasn't erased who they fundamentally are.
Your loved one would never choose to hurt you this way. The very fact that their accusations hurt is evidence of the deep love between you—a love that exists even when it can't be expressed in ways either of you recognize.
Things to Try This Week
Create your emotional first-aid kit: Write down the three most hurtful things your loved one says, then create a specific response for each that you can practice and have ready. Mine includes phrases like, "I can see you're worried about your things. I'm here to help, not take anything from you."
Give yourself one guilt-free hour: I mean it. Schedule 60 minutes this week where someone else is responsible for your loved one, and do something exclusively for you. The caregiving will be there when you return, but you'll come back stronger.
Remember: When they can no longer express their love for you, how you care for yourself becomes an expression of your love for them.
We're in this together.
Understanding Dementia's Stages
Navigating the Journey
Living with dementia—whether as someone diagnosed or as a caregiver—means embarking on a journey with distinct challenges at each turn. Understanding what lies ahead can help families prepare emotionally, financially, and logistically for the changes to come.
Early Stage: Recognizing the Signs
The early stage of dementia often begins subtly.
Someone might experience:
- Forgetfulness that goes beyond typical age-related memory changes
- Difficulty finding the right words during conversations
- Challenges with planning or organizing daily tasks
- Misplacing items in unusual places
- Mood changes, including anxiety or depression about cognitive difficulties
During this stage, most people can still live independently, drive, work, and maintain social relationships. However, they may need reminders for appointments, medications, or important events.
Planning ahead: This is the optimal time to have important conversations about future care preferences, legal documents (power of attorney, advance directives), and financial planning. The person with dementia should be actively involved in these discussions while they can still clearly express their wishes.
Care approach: Focus on maintaining independence while providing gentle support. Create simple routines, use reminder systems, and encourage social engagement and mentally stimulating activities.
Middle Stage: Adapting to Increasing Needs
The middle stage typically lasts the longest and brings more noticeable challenges:
- Increased forgetfulness, especially about recent events
- Difficulty recognizing friends and family
- Confusion about time and place
- Personality and behavioral changes, including suspicion or agitation
- Need for assistance with daily activities like dressing or bathing
- Sleep disturbances and wandering behaviors
During this stage, more supervision and assistance become necessary. Many families find they need to consider in-home care services or adult day programs.
Planning ahead: Evaluate the home environment for safety and consider modifications like removing tripping hazards, installing grab bars, or using door alarms. Research respite care options and support groups for caregivers.
Care approach: Establish structured routines while remaining flexible. Break tasks into simple steps, use clear, calm communication, and focus on remaining abilities rather than lost skills. Remember that challenging behaviors often stem from unmet needs or confusion rather than intentional defiance.
Late Stage: Providing Comfort and Dignity
In the late stage, individuals require extensive assistance with all aspects of daily living:
- Limited awareness of surroundings and recent experiences
- Difficulty communicating verbally
- Vulnerability to infections and physical complications
- Complete dependence for personal care needs
- Possible difficulty with swallowing and mobility
Planning ahead: Consider palliative care options and how to maximize quality of life. Have conversations about end-of-life wishes if not already addressed.
Care approach: Focus shifts from encouraging independence to ensuring comfort and dignity. Sensory connections become increasingly important—gentle touch, soothing music, familiar scents, and the sound of loved ones’ voices can provide comfort even when verbal communication is limited.
Adjusting Expectations Throughout the Journey
Perhaps the most challenging aspect of dementia care is continually recalibrating expectations. What worked yesterday may not work today, and the person you’ve known for years may behave in unfamiliar ways.
Some guiding principles that help across all stages:
- Meet the person where they are, not where you expect them to be
- Look for the meaning behind behaviors rather than taking them personally
- Celebrate small victories and find moments of joy
- Take care of yourself as a caregiver—you cannot pour from an empty cup
- Remember that the essence of the person remains even as abilities change
Compassion as Your North Star
While dementia progresses differently for each person, understanding these general stages can help families navigate the journey with greater confidence. The path may not be straight, and there will likely be plateaus and unexpected turns. Through it all, compassion—for the person with dementia and for yourself as a caregiver—serves as the most reliable guide.
Take Action Now
Don’t wait for a crisis to begin preparing for the dementia journey:
- Schedule a family meeting to discuss care preferences and responsibilities
- Consult with an elder law attorney about essential legal documents
- Connect with your local Alzheimer’s Association chapter for education and support
Remember, you’re not alone on this journey. Reaching out for information and support is not just helpful—it’s essential.
—
**This article is meant for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult healthcare professionals for guidance specific to your situation. **